Indium Corporation
From One Engineer to Another®

Patty Presents Her Electronics Assembly Copy Exactly Strategy

Monday, February 20, 2012 by Dr. Ron Lasky [Dr. Ron Lasky]

Folks,

Patty is getting ready for her meeting on "Copy Exactly" with Mike Madigan.......

It was after 6:30 PM and Patty was just arriving home.  Since Patty was working late, Rob had agreed to make his signature dish, crispy macaroni and cheese.  Patty and Pete had just finished their project to develop a copy exactly strategy for ACME.  They would present it tomorrow to CEO Mike Madigan.  The local GM, Sam Watkins, would be there too.  Technically Mike was her boss in her Senior VP position, but since she had an office at the ACME facility in Exeter, NH, she reported to Sam - “dotted line.”  Patty had been working late for weeks on this project and was glad that the greatest portion of the work was over.

As she opened the door to her house, her twin 2 year old boys ran up to her in their excitement to see their mom and nearly knocked her over.  She tussled with them for a few minutes and then went to give Rob a hug.  He had the dinner on the table and they all quickly sat down.  Rob and Patty had a "no technology" rule at meals…..no mobile phones, iPads etc.  Meal time was family time.  After discussing the events of the day, Rob’s face lit up.

“I found out today that there is something we look at more than anything else,” Rob stated.

“OK, OK, let me guess,” Patty replied.

After a number of tries, she hadn’t gotten it.

Alright, I give up, Patty said with playful exasperation.

Indium, or really Indium Tin Oxide (ITO), it is a transparent conductor of electricity.  We look through it when we look at our computer, tablet or mobile phone screens.  Think about it, for most of us we probably look through ITO for 8 to 10 hours a day.  It’s like we have a love affair with the stuff,” Rob explained.

Patty almost choked on some of the mac and cheese on the last comment.

“Why have you become such an expert on this stuff?” Patty asked.

“Well, you remember that ACME may go into component assembly? Sam asked me to look into indium thermal interface material (TIM)  for some of the component packages that need to dissipate a lot of heat,” Rob answered.

Patty knew a little bit about TIMs, but not about ITO.

“But why did you learn about ITO?” she asked.

“Sam is worried that Indium supplies may not be enough to satisfy TIM requirements, so he asked me to look into it,” Rob answered.

“What is the conclusion? Patty asked.

“Well, Indium is about as common in the earth’s crust as silver, but a little more difficult to extract.  This probably gives it the reputation of being rare.  Fortunately for me a recent analysis was performed that showed that the indium supply will be more than adequate for the next 75 years ,” Rob said.

Rob went on, “Indium is a very interesting material, it is one of the few materials that wets glass, so it enables metal sealing to glass.  It was only discovered in 1863 and it wasn’t until the 1930s that the first practical use for indium was discovered: aircraft bearing lubrication.  In a sense, it could be argued that it is one of the materials of the future, as we are just now learning about its potential.”

While he was talking, Rob reached into his backpack and took something out.

“Look at this, or rather listen,” Rob said.

With that, he took a thin bar of metal and bent it. A crackling sound came from the metal.  Patty was fascinated.

“What was that?" she asked.

“When a thin bar of indium is bent, it gives off a sound.  It is called “Indium Cry.”  The salesman for the TIMs we are using let me borrow it for a presentation I am giving to Sam Watkins next week,” Rob answered.

Dinner was soon finished and Patty had to get the boys to bed after playing with them for awhile.  Today was Spanish day and all of their discussions were in that language.  Another day was Mandarin Chinese day.  The boys already understood the three languages spoken at home.

A few hours later, Patty lay in bed - energized by the thought of her meeting tomorrow.

When she woke up the next day, she exercised at home, ate breakfast, and took the boys to day care.  See arrived at the office 30 minutes before the big meeting.  After checking emails, she went to the conference room where the meeting would be held, to set up her computer.  At precisely 8AM, Mike Madigan and Sam Watkins arrived.

“OK Coleman, let’s get this show on the road,” Madigan commanded.

“Since our last meeting we have analyzed assembly equipment and materials to determine which ones would be best for a copy exactly strategy,” Patty began.

She then showed her third slide and spoke to it.

“The winner for component placement equipment is Optoplace, as are their stencil printer and reflow ovens.  Exactotest makes the winning testers and ElectoMaterials the best solder paste and solder preforms,” Patty went on.

“Can you explain your methodology?” Sam asked.

“We looked at what The Professor calls ‘Profit Potential,’ simply the equipment and material that gives the most profit, assuming you are running a well tuned organization.  Fortunately, since ACME has 80 assembly lines we were able to get real process performance data on all of the major machines available, ” Patty answered.

“You answer seems a little evasive, why didn’t you use ‘Cost of Ownership?’” Madigan challenged.

“Some machines cost less to own, but they are down more for assists and when they need repair, we have to wait longer for the repair man.  From what The Professor taught us, uptime is very important. Anything that hurts uptime, like a late repairman or a machine that needs more assist time, will hurt profits.  The same is true for materials like solder paste.  If they cost less, but result in line downtime for response to pause issues or some other fault, they hurt profitability.” Patty responded.

Just then Sam’s administrative assistant, Clare Perkins opened the door.

“As you requested Mr. Madigan, your guest is joining the meeting,” Clare said.

“Well Torant, looks like Coleman said you lost,” Madigan said to the new arrival.

Upon seeing Rex Torant, Patty became a little unsettled and Pete turned his famous crimson red.  Patty and Pete called him “Rex the Torrent” as he spoke so rapidly when trying to sell them something.  Both found this manufacturer’s “rep” annoying.

“Everyone, I invited Rex to the meeting.  We met at the airport last night and started chatting.  He assured me that his Pinnacle equipment line and Ultima solder paste would be the winners today since they have the lowest cost of ownership,” Madigan explained.

Torant saw the slide announce Optoplace, Exactotest and ElectoMaterials as the winners.

“My products are just as reliable and cost 30% a year less to own,” Torant fumed at Patty.

Patty had not anticipated Torant’s attendance at the meeting but had prepared for this type of question.

“Mr. Torant is correct, however Pinnacle’s component placement machines have more downtime for machine assists and, when the equipment does malfunction, it is down for repairs on average for 28 hrs, whereas Optoplace is only down for 14 hrs.  All in all, Optoplace machines are up 6 hrs more a week in a two shift operation,” Patty calmly responded.

Will Patty’s arguments win the day?  Can a 30% more expensive machine really have more “Profit Potential?”  And what about the solder paste and materials?  Stay tuned.

Cheers,

Dr. Ron

 

image

Is Lowest "Cost of Ownership" the Best Electronics Assembly Manufacturing Metric?

Tuesday, February 14, 2012 by Dr. Ron Lasky [Dr. Ron Lasky]

Folks,

Let's look in on Patty and her colleagues......

New HampshireSam Watkins, ACME New Hampshire site GM, had just finished meeting with his boss, ACME CEO Mike Madigan. He was embarrassed that these meetings always stressed him; Mike was an intimidating character. Still, why should he be nervous? Things were going really well. Profits were up at all sites since NMAC/I/O was implemented as their new profitability metric. Patty Coleman, who suggested this metric, visited all of the ACME sites with weaker NMAC/I/O and profits, and, after performing process audits, helped these sites get their acts together. Oh, and we can’t forget Pete Ortiz, who works for Patty. They seemed to have a terrific synergistic relationship. He was an integral part of this success story.

Sam started writing an email to Patty. He and Mike concluded that, building on the recent NMAC/I/O success, they need to make ACME a “copy exactly” company. They agreed that if they were implementing a copy exactly strategy they should do it with the most cost effective assembly equipment and materials. It seemed to both of them that that the lowest “cost of ownership” should be the most important metric in this strategy. Sam finished his note to Patty asking (ordering) her to implement this strategy. She was to present a plan to achieve this goal to Sam and Mike in 6 weeks. Her presentation was to include the recommended equipment and materials, a phase-in plan, the budget needed to achieve the goal, and the projected ROI of the endeavor.

Patty was in her office having lunch while reading Golf Digest and USA Today. She looked up at her laptop screen and saw Sam's email. Reading it energized her. She was happiest when working on a significant project. After digesting the contents she thought she would call The Professor and ask his advice. Sam and Mike had insisted that she put The Professor on a retainer as he had added so much value to ACME. Patty had to chuckle, it was hard to get him to send in his bill; he seemed little motivated by money.

The Professor would never tell her how many languages he spoke, so she was going to try a little French on him.  She and Rob had been studying it at home.

“Bonjour Professeur, comment ca va?” Patty cheerfully said as The Professor answered the phone.

“Très bien Patty. Comment sont Rob et vos fils? Ma femme et moi avons été inquiets au sujet de Rob. Est-ce le dos guérit bien?” The Professor replied with a Parisian accent. (Very well Patty. How are Rob and your sons? My wife and I have been worried about Rob. Is his back healing well?)

Patty sighed and thought, “Well that makes about 10 languages I have verified so far.”

“Rob is doing quite well. Word got around and my Lean Six Sigma Green Belt instructor, Jim Hall called and shared his thoughts with me about over doing it in exercise programs. Jim is a fitness instructor and a big believer in moderate exercise. Rob has promised me to tone it down a lot,” Patty answered.

“I’m relieved,” said The Professor, “Rob needs to be healthy to keep up with your sons.”

“But, I imagine you have some business to discuss,” the Professor went right to the point.

“Yes, Sam and Mike want me to head up implementing a copy exactly program with equipment and materials, and they are strongly suggesting that the equipment and materials have the lowest cost of ownership,” Patty summarized.

“Copy exactly can be very beneficial, if the materials and equipment are good choices,” The Professor answered thoughtfully.

“But I have real problems with ‘Lowest Cost of Ownership.’ It is a good metric to compare something like automobiles, but to compare equipment or materials that are used to generate a profit it can be misused.” he replied.

Patty felt she understood where he was going, but wanted to hear it from him.

“Can you give an example?” she asked.

The Professor answered, “Let’s say a man mow lawns for a living. He considers two lawn mowers for his business, one is a push mower that cuts a 20 inch path and costs $300. Assume he takes 3 years to pay off the loan to buy it. Maintenance is $150 per year and fuel is $1200 for a 30 week season. The other is a sit down lawn mower that costs $3000, with $500 maintenance per year and it uses $3,000 in fuel per year. It cuts a 50 inch path. Which has the lower ‘Cost of Ownership?’”

“That’s easy,” Patty said, “the 20 inch push mower.” “But clearly the lowest cost of ownership is meaningless,” she went on.

“Explain,” replied the professor.

Patty answered, “Well, the man is in business to optimize profit. Clearly he can mow more laws with the sit down mower. Let’s say with the push mower he can do 4 lawns a day and with the sit down mower he can do 10 lawns a day. We can also assume he gets $35 per lawn. So, for a New Hampshire 30-week lawn mowing year, he earns 4x7x30x$35 = $29,400 with the push mower and 10x7x30x$35 = $73,500 with the sit down mower. Let me make a spreadsheet to determine the profit in each case.”

Lawn Mower BusinessPatty was one of those young people who could type so fast that it made The Professor’s head spin. In seconds she had a spreadsheet developed.

“Wow, with the push mower he only makes $27,950 and with the riding mower he makes $69,000!” Patty exclaimed.

“And the same is true in electronics assembly. The best equipment, solder paste, solder preforms, underfill, cored solder wire, and solder fluxes are the ones that help your company make the most profit. Not the ones that have the ‘lowest cost of ownership,’” The Professor summed up.

To be continued.....

Cheers,

Dr. Ron

image

Tin/Silver Solder Paste in Die Attach (Sn/Ag)

Tuesday, July 26, 2011 by Dr. Andy Mackie [Dr. Andy Mackie]
IGBT Ag/Sn SolderA customer at Semicon West this year asked about Pb-free solder usage in die-attach applications. Although many smaller discrete components are attached using high melting, high reliability, and high lead (Pb) solders, the die-attach method of choice for many IGBT manufacturers is the tin-silver eutectic (96.5Sn/3.5Ag), which has the known advantages of:
 
  • High thermal conductivity (33W/mK)
  • Higher melting point than SAC alloys (221C)
  • Low tensile stress, so suitable for large die (5800psi)
  • Excellent thermal cycling properties (-55 to 125C)


The solder can be applied in a number of different ways onto the substrate in Power Semiconductor applications:
  1.  Preform (a specially-shaped solder piece) with TACflux® used to hold the preform and die in place
  2.  Solder paste, which holds the die in place with no extra materials added 
  3.  Soft solder die-attach wire, a fluxless type of solder wire, which is melted onto the substrate metallization under an inert cover gas, and the die directly mounted onto the molten solder pool, then allowed to cool.

Heat transfer through the baseplate and direct-bonded copper (DBC) makes 1/ and 2/ (above) the preferred method of attachment for IGBT modules. By using a vacuum reflow process, it is also possible to make even solder paste (which always seems to generate some voids, even in standard processes) almost void-free, which was demonstrated in our recent paper.

Cheers!  Andy

Options for Attaching Power Amplifiers: Soldering & Thermal Management

Thursday, May 12, 2011 by Seth Homer [Seth Homer]

Power amplifiers and transistors come in many shapes and sizes. The performance requirements vary as well. Attaching them can be a critical aspect of your design.

TIM DATABoth Pb and Pb-free alloys can be manufactured as a solder preform with a flux coating.(Learn more)  Selecting the right alloy and flux coating can be crucial to meeting your void criteria.  

A high-tech SOLDERING solution might include NanoFoil®, which effects a solder joint while minimizing heat exposure to your components.

There are also thermal interface materials such as the HEAT-SPRING® which utilize the unique properties of indium to create a superior thermal connection, similar to a solder joint.

There are many different attachment methods available, contact me with your design parameters and we can find your solution.  

Indium Thermal Evaporation Sources

Wednesday, May 12, 2010 by Jim Hisert [Jim Hisert]

In the surface mount technology (SMT) electronics and semiconductor packaging industries, Indium Corporation has a reputation for offering custom solutions.  In the world of solar cell manufacturing, I hope that same status is obvious.  I feel custom solutions are even MORE important in emerging technology fields like CIGS cell manufacturing.  Being the leading global supplier of indium (the metal), and a supplier of unique solder alloy shape/size/tolerance forms, we are well equipped to offer you evaporation sources that are tailored to your application.  Sure, we can supply round shot, teardrop shot, wire, ingot, preforms, and various other bulk forms of solder to keep your evaporation chamber filled.  Did you know we can also make custom solder castings to fit your particular crucible?  The process is easy, let us know if you are interested!

 

(Just click here to get started)

Unique Solderspheres

Wednesday, April 21, 2010 by Dr. Andy Mackie [Dr. Andy Mackie]

Solderspheres or solder spheres, or even solder balls: whatever you call them, Indium Corporation has been making them for years and has rightly acquired the reputation for doing whatever it takes to meet our customers' unique needs.

Unique Alloys:

Hard to find alloys (like multipart alloys; low-melting alloys and even gold/tin (80Au/20Sn)) are our bread and butter. As "Indium Corporation" it should be no surprise that we lead the world in our ability to supply low-melting indium-alloy solder spheres, as well as other forms of these alloys, such as engineered solders or solder pastes.

Unique Quantities:

We don't want you to buy more than you absolutely need. If you just want 100 spheres, we can easily do that: if you want more - we can do that, too. But remember that, because each customer's need is unique, our prices may be higher than our competitors, especially for more standard alloys. Some customers also have unique inventory-control needs, so we work with many customers to ship on-demand by retaining a buffer stock of spheres here at Indium.

Unique Sizes:

Our current dimensional capabilities as of this writing are from 80microns to 0.062inches, or even bigger. Generally, the bigger the sphere - the less spherical it is (within the limits of surface tension and viscosity), and we can't control the laws of physics, so instances where a very large amount of solder is needed, a preform may have better dimensional control. Also, notice that we won't ask that you order in a specific unit of diameter measurement, like the mil or the micron or the millimeter: we're a global company - just tell us what you need.

Unique Packaging:

Often needed for more delicate alloy spheres, we can offer specialty overpacking that eliminates oxides from the atmosphere around the solder spheres, essentially stopping oxidation in its tracks. It's the same technique we use to package our soft solder die-attach (SSDA) wire: a technique that showed that the very reactive wire was still "as new" 3 years later. We also offer spheres in tape & reel packaging (see image) for 24mil, 35mil and 62mil diameter spheres.

Unique Tolerances:

Just as a case in point, a MEMS customer of ours had a need for a low-melting indium-alloy solder sphere with a tolerance of +/-5microns (+/-0.005mm) for a sphere with a 350micron diameter. That demands a tolerance of just over 1% - pretty demanding, but we did it.

Our standard tolerance is +/-1mil (1 thousandth of an inch, or 25.4microns), but as you can see, we have the capability to go to much tighter tolerances using three proprietary manufacturing techniques.

Other Needs:

We are also seeing people asking for doped-alloy spheres; low-alpha emission solder spheres and other things that we could never have dreamed of...

So please just let us know what you need. We'd be happy to help out, and if we can not do what you ask - we'll let you know why.

Cheers!  Andy


Recent Electronics Assembly Trends

Friday, March 5, 2010 by Christopher Nash [Christopher Nash]

shot clockI love watching a good basketball game, and one of my favorite local teams is the Syracuse Orangemen. If you go to a Syracuse home game, notice the shot clock – it was made with Indium Corporation solder. There are a lot of places you can see our products in your everyday life. That smart phone in your pocket, the electrical components in your car, the thermal interface in the computer in front of you. That’s one of the things that makes this job rewarding, being part of so many various applications.

 

In addition to learning about these different applications, we also get a good reference for what assembly trends are developing, and which material technologies are becoming more popular. 

 

I’ve watched the halogen-free trend explode and fade, as it was adopted by some large OEMs and their contract manufacturers, but has not spread to most other companies. Another trend that is fading away from the spotlight is Pb-free die-attach solder, since the EU has not found a suitable replacement and has pushed back the exemption deadline. 

 

A long-existing topic that has had recent mention is solder jetting. The trend towards soldering smaller components is not new or surprising, but for smaller components (01005s and 0201s) we have seen a trend towards dispensing instead of jetting – which seems to suit those applications.

 

For small component printing, transfer efficiency is critical. Outside of solder paste optimization, “nano-stencil” technology is an upcoming technology that may take-off and improve paste release characteristics. Solder paste is being used in some other creative ways too, like low temperature alloy dipping paste for rework operations. Manycompanies are now using or evaluating specialized solder applications to replace components without fully reflowing the rest of the components on the board.

 

Integrated preforms are finding their way into more and more applications recently as well. These connected preforms are being used to reduce the need for component pallets and selective soldering operations.


All these applications are great ways that our customers are taking soldering technology to the next level, using materials and assembly methods that were not common before. I look forward to learning how you’d like to use solder in your application!

Lead (Pb) in ELV Solder: European Automotive Electronics Legislation - Feb 2010 Update

Thursday, March 4, 2010 by Dr. Andy Mackie [Dr. Andy Mackie]

Those of you have been watching this blog for a while will know that I’ve been keeping tabs on the status of the European ELV (End-of-life vehicle) legislation on lead (Pb), mercury (Hg), cadmium (Cd) and hexavalent chromium (CrVI). It’s been both galling and heartening at the same time, to find that when I Google “elv legislation”, this (my) blog keeps coming up as one of the top 10 sources on the subject. OK: enough of the bloggy, solipsistic prevarication...

 

My friend, Geert Willems of IMEC late last week let me know that the EC (European Commission) had given its final decisions on Annex II ("the exceptions"), and pretty much adopted the recommendations of the Öko Institute from their 127 page report of September last year (2009). I have to say my hat is off to Dr. Otmar Deubzer of IZM and Stéphanie Zangl of Öko for the very thorough and logical background to this legislation.

 

The decisions that affect those of us in the semiconductor (flip-chip) and power semiconductor arena are primarily the ones on lead (Pb) in solders, that were formerly covered by section 8.a/ and 8.b/ of the old, outdated Annex II to Directive 2000/53/EC, and are now covered by this new legislation.

 

A quick visual summary of the legislation relevant to lead (Pb) in electrical interconnects is given below, and please consult the original document for confirmation, as I may have missed some subtlety of the legalese in my quest for brevity. Also, frankly, subsection 8 (b) led to some Transatlantic confusion over whether finishes on pin connectors and PWB's were covered(?), but I think the below is correct:




Refer to the table below for the timeline for of each subsection/exception:



Note that the last review of exemptions was carried out in 2009, with potential effect by 1/1/2011. This implies that the legislative hammer will potentially fall on each of those usages slated for future review on January 1st two years after the review year. Lead (Pb) for most electronics attach usages of interest to those of us in semiconductor and power semiconductor packaging may therefore be "legislated out" by 1/1/2016.

Basically, the use of Pb-containing solders in solder paste, die-attach paste, die-attach wire, solder preforms, and thermal interface materials (TIMs) in automotive electronics assembly is safe for now, and changes will not be forced on the automotive electronics assembly industry at a time when even current manufacturing practises may be leading to still-unresolved safety incidents.

Cheers!  Andy

Packaging and Handling of Integrated Preforms® For Solder Fortification

Sunday, January 10, 2010 by Paul Socha [Paul Socha]

Integrated Preforms®, like separate solder preforms, are available in all of the common shapes. Since not all applications are alike, these connected preforms will vary, not only in the alloy, but also in the size and shape of the solder preform required to deliver the correct amount of solder to the joint.

 

Some Integrated Preforms are made into discs, squares and rectangles for surface mount applications. Generally, the most common shape is that of a washer - for attaching through-hole components to a printed circuit board. Regardless of the shape, each is designed with specific dimensions that will fit the application. The spacing between the washers also varies because the pins on through-hole components can have different pitches.

 

Connected Integrated PreformsIntegrated Preforms are manufactured in 5” x 9” sheets with the designed shapes positioned within the borders. In preparation for shipment, they are stacked with lint-free paper and backing board and placed in a vacuum-sealed bag for delivery to the customer.

 

The customer can easily cut the shapes from the sheets with scissors or an X-Acto® blade. Care must be taken to handle the solder preforms with gloves so as not to contaminate the sheets with unwanted surface organics which could lead to voiding.

 

The next blog in this series will address the actual use of the Integrated Preforms and the many ways they can be modified to fit any application.

Tips to Speed Your Solder and Flux Selection

Tuesday, January 5, 2010 by Jim Hisert [Jim Hisert]

Today I made my rounds in the office, collecting ideas for you from our tech guys  - ideas to help you speed the alloy and flux selection process.  The team gave me ideas from the start of the design process all the way up to speeding the order process, and all the steps in between.  These are solder basics, but they can help you get your process up on its feet quicker - if you put together a little information up-front:

1) Call a tech guy early, but be prepared by knowing the specifics of your material needs, like powder size, flux type, and any design requirements.

 

2) If you’re an engineer specializing in component attachment, get yourself involved with the component or board design team. It may mean extra meetings, but it will save many headaches in the long run after you help the team remember the meaning of “design for manufacture”.

 

3) Define the details of your application, equipment, and process before selecting a material. For instance, knowing the needle size that you will be utilizing in a dispense machine will speed the powder size selection for die-attach solder paste.

 

4) Be aware of cleaning requirements and your current in-house cleaning equipment and chemicals before choosing a flux or flux vehicle.

 

5) Understand the operational temperature of your assembly and the maximum processing temperatures of the components. This will make alloy selection much faster.

 

6) Don’t get hung up at the ordering process – know what size packaging you need. Do you have equipment that only fits a certain size syringe or cartridge?  Knowing this ahead of time will save you a second call to verify while talking with an Account Specialist.

 

7) For alloy compatibility and metallurgical considerations, be prepared to lets us know the composition and thickness of your surface finish. This will also save a second call, because it is required information in order for us to get you the right alloy and the perfect flux for your application.

 

8) For solder paste printing recommendations, know the specifications of the stencil you will be using. Aperture size, stencil thickness, and any other dimensions you can provide will help guide which flux vehicle and powder size we will recommend to you.

 

9) For preform selection, try using thinner preforms. For prototype situations you can stack the thinner preforms to build solder volume, and it is much quicker to order preforms in 1 thickness as opposed to many thicknesses.

 

10) Understand your process bottlenecks. By letting us know your material needs we can usually suggest a few materials, but perhaps one of those materials can help eliminate a problem that is slowing your process down.

 

11) Consider your company’s roadmap for the next 5 years. It doesn’t make sense to select a material and need to select a new one only a year later. Save yourself the time involved in a second solder evaluation and know what the future holds regarding safety/environmental concerns. Likewise, understand the roadmap of your supplier, their future materials, and how their current materials will fit your company’s future plans.

The final piece of the puzzle

Monday, November 30, 2009 by Carol Gowans [Carol Gowans]
Solder fortification solutionThere is nothing more frustrating than going through an entire process (whether it is putting together a puzzle or manufacturing a product) only to find the final piece missing. 

That final piece can be the strength of the solder joints which can impact the quality of your product or the amount of rework that needs to be done.  As the products get smaller and the solder paste stencils get thinner, the ability to get enough solder paste to adequately hold shields, components and connectors gets harder and harder.

So what is that final piece of the puzzle?  Consider Solder Fortification Preforms.  These are solder preforms, which are solid pieces of solder, that are added to a solder paste deposit to give it the additional volume required to create a stronger joint.  They generally come in sizes similar to components, such as 0402 and 0603, and are packaged in tape & reel like the components so they are easily placed with standard pick and place equipment.

The additional solder can improve your first past yields and reduce field failures.  Now that is the perfect final piece to complete the picture!

Eutectic Gold Tin (AuSn)

Tuesday, September 22, 2009 by Amanda Hartnett [Amanda Hartnett]

Eutectic Gold Tin (AuSn) with a composition of 80Au20Sn is a unique material.  This particular alloy of gold tin (AuSn) is considered a solder because it has a melting temperature of 280ºC, which is lower than the 350ºC transition temperature into braze materials.  Still, there are some similarities between this solder alloy and braze alloys. The most obvious is the hardness of the gold tin (AuSn) alloy. With a tensile strength of 40,000PSI, this solder is much more rigid than the tin solders most are familiar with. The strength is more closely compared to the silver brazes which melt above 500ºC. 

 

With that strength has come some unique manufacturing difficulties. For many years, one obstacle for implementation of gold tin (AuSn) as a solder preform or wire, was its availability in thin forms or fine diameters. The gold tin (AuSn) is extremely hard and it became brittle as it was handled through manufacturing and would crack if it was pressed too thin or fine.  

 

Luckily, in the 40+ years since eutectic gold tin (AuSn) was first used in electronics manufacturing, processing techniques have come a long way.  Today, gold tin (AuSn) solder can be made into dimensions much smaller than the soft solders, allowing it to be used in applications which require the highest level of precision.

 

Typical dimensions and tolerances of gold tin (AuSn) can be found in the below chart.



 

This chart as well as more detail on gold tin (AuSn) applications are available in the paper titled, “Process and Reliability Advantages of AuSn Eutectic Die-Attach,” presented at IMAPS 2009.    


Lead Free Alloy Selection

Thursday, September 17, 2009 by Carol Gowans [Carol Gowans]

Ignoring the solder selection as part of your design process is risky business. 

 

As Terry Costlow, the IPC online editor of EMS Now noted in an article ‘Controlling the Explosion of Lead Free Solders’, the choice of the right solder alloy can affect the manufacturing process, the cost, and the field performance of the product.

 

Initially it was thought that the move to Pb free solders was just a matter of changing reflow profiles but major issues such as tin whiskers, brittle intermetallic layers and other concerns soon pushed solder selection into the forefront.

 

With over 200 published alloys and over 300 custom alloys shipped each year, we have seen the need for considering the solder design first.  Before you settle on a solder you have to consider:

·         Surface metallizations

·         Operational temperature of your product or device

·         Form of the solder you want to use (solder paste, solder preform, solder wire, etc.)

·         Temperature of subsequent soldering steps

·         Thermal coefficient of expansion

·         Tensile strength

 

And these are just a few of the considerations.  Let us help you make the right selection.  Contact us at: askus@indium.com.

 

Feel free to discuss solder selection with our industry professional, Dr. Lasky on November 11th, IPC is having a materials conference: Engineering for Compliance in Irvine, CA.

 

Solar Products and Representatives

Wednesday, September 2, 2009 by Jim Hisert [Jim Hisert]

A reader of this blog recently mentioned: "I am interested in what products could be sold by manufacturer's representatives."  That is a large question, considering the evolution that we have come to expect in the solar industry.  To answer that question involves first breaking up the industry into 2 separate sections, front and back end solar assembly.  Front end assembly involves the process of making the solar cell.  Back end involves connecting cells together and assembling them to create a useable device.

 

Both front and back end products are going to be geared to the customer's technology.  For instance, if I was purchasing materials for a large thin-film manufacturing company and someone boldly offered me glass filled high-temperature metallization paste, I would tell them to come back when they know what they are talking about.  (In reality, I'd be nice – even though it's an incredibly ignorant mistake.)  With that in mind, let's focus on what back end products a representative might be offering for crystalline and thin film solar customers – assuming that back end begins after metallization:

 

  • Outsourced Solar Cells
  • Tabbing Ribbon
  • Bus Ribbon
  • Tabbing Flux
  • Solder Paste
  • Preforms
  • Solder Wire
  • Tacky-type Fluxes
  • Tabbing Equipment
  • Rework Equipment
  • Test Equipment/Services
  • Packaging Materials
  • Junction Boxes
  • Laminate Materials
  • Silicone/Sealing Materials
  • Passive Components
  • Ovens
  • Frames
  • Gloves / Lab Coats / Safety Equipment

 

I probably left out as many possible line items as I included, but I hope you get the idea.  Feel free to add the ones I forgot in the comment section below.

 

~Jim

 

INTERVIEW: Klaus Roehmer: PINK Vacuum Reflow

Wednesday, August 19, 2009 by Dr. Andy Mackie [Dr. Andy Mackie]
Figure 1: 15% Voiding with air reflow

Figure 1: 15% Voiding with air reflow

Figure 2: ~0% Voiding after vacuum reflow

Figure 2: ~0% Voiding after vacuum reflow

Figure 3: Multiple voids

Figure 3: Multiple voids

While at the Semicon West 2009 show in July, I had a chance to sit down with Herr Klaus Roemer of Pink GmbH. PINK is most famous in the die-attach and power module manufacturing world for their reflow ovens with vacuum, but are also known in the medical and aerospace industries for manufacturing extremely high precision, one-off, vacuum equipment for applications as diverse as particle-accelerators for ion bombardment, and large-volume chambers for helium leak-detection. I asked him some questions about Pink vacuum soldering technology.

ACM: Why do people use vacuum soldering?
 
Klaus:
Shrinking package sizes and higher power density in electronic devices necessitate void-free soldering. Voids reduce the electrical and thermal conductivity and cause hot spots, which are very critical especially in the case of power electronics. The pressure in voids is usually around 1bar (ambient pressure). A vacuum of < 5 mbar (4 Torr) in the soldering chamber causes a differential pressure between the voids in the liquid solder and outside the solder connection, resulting in a force that effectively "pulls out" the voids against the resistance of the solder viscosity. Figures 1 and 2 show the dramatic difference in voiding on a direct-bonded copper baseplate for an IGBT module.
 
ACM: Don't other manufacturers also produce vacuum soldering equipment?
 
Klaus: Yes, we have some very capable competitors, but they usually can only solder with high temperature and preforms only, and not with solder paste. PINK has a unique patented technology which offers the following significant advantages:
 
·         Void-free soldering in inline systems for mass production or batch type ovens
·         Soldering with solder paste (highly efficient flux management system) and / or soldering with preforms
·         Flux free soldering possible, by using formic acid or forming gas
·         Temperature profiles in accordance with IPC / JEDEC or customers specifications, with a short process time of typically 6 minutes only
·         Adjustable and controlled temperature gradients
·         Process temperatures up to 400°C
·         Consistent process control and traceability
 
ACM: How does PINK manage the fast heat transfer required for precisely controlled heating and cooling?
 
Klaus: In each heating zone within the oven, a large block with a high thermal mass is heated to a constant temperature, and is then raised to touch the platen on which the substrate is resting. The number and the time period of "touches" of the thermal mass against the platen dictate its temperature and heating gradient, allowing a very precise profile control, using a PID-controller feedback-loop. Cooling is done the same way, with a vice versa heat flow. An efficient flux- management system in the "VADU" by PINK allows 24/7 production. Liquid flux residues can easily be removed by just opening taps in the flux collection reservoirs. Burning of flux residues is prevented by using a spike reflow  temperature which is only about 20°C higher than the soldering temperature.
 
Our Youtube video shows this process very well. You can see the "bubbling and boiling" of the reflowed solder paste, as flux volatiles expand under the die, and outgas.
Voids are typically found to be less than 1%, often zero and although many customers always ask for always "zero voids" this is difficult to achieve, due to variations in the substrate and die finishes.
 
ACM: Klaus, das war sehr interessant! Danke für die Informationen.
 
---
 
Andy Mackie comment:
 
Don't forget that each time that a void appears under a die, it increases the current density (A / cm2) as an inverse function of the void cross-sectional area. In a situation where there is a lot of voiding, this can lead to thermal runaway. For example (figure 3) in the case of a junction between several voids, the thin films of solder between the voids may heat up to higher temperatures, as the voids will not conduct heat. This becomes a vicious cycle, where the hotter film of solder has a lower resistance, so carries more current, so gets heated up more, and so on, and in some instances the die may actually be "blown" off the direct bonded copper substrate by the pressure in the expanding void, combined with the weak or even molten solder.

Cheers! Andy

Au/Sn Perfected

Monday, June 1, 2009 by Carol Gowans [Carol Gowans]
A passage from Metals Handbook, Volume 6, 1983Ӕ

A passage from Metals Handbook, Volume 6, 1983Ӕ

Fact: To achieve a strong, reliable solder joint, it is important to remove all oxides from the substrate as well as the solder.  Generally this is done using a compatible flux.

 

Reality: Sometimes flux cannot be used, so it is important that the starting materials be as oxide-free as possible.  Au/Sn is a popular solder in flux-less applications. The preform is a popular form for Au/Sn because it delivers a consistent, controlled amount of solder every time.  However, unless properly controlled, the manufacturing process can introduce oxides that become imbedded in the material and cannot be easily cleaned.

 

Solution: Indium Corporation has perfected its process used to manufacture Au/Sn preforms.  This is no small task.  Our experienced Metallurgists and Process Engineers have taken a good thing and made it even better.  If you're looking for proof, talk with one of our Application Engineers about evaluating Indium Corp. Au/Sn preforms in your process!

 

SMT Goes Solar

Thursday, March 19, 2009 by Jim Hisert [Jim Hisert]

I'm excited about the May 2009 issue of SMT magazine, which will be highlighting photovoltaic soldering applications.  Not only does it combine soldering and PV (which is our niche), but it will be including an article written by Karl Pfluke of the Indium Corporation.  (Abstract shown below)  Karl's one of my personal heroes, he's a veteran technical engineer and leader in solar applications.

 

Photovoltaic Stringing in Solar Cell Module Assembly

By Karl Pfluke

Indium Corporation

 

"As more and more contract manufacturers (CMs) look for opportunities to diversify and fill factory space, photovoltaic (PV) solar cell module assembly seems to be the popular choice.  Commonly referred to in the solar panel industry as the "back end process", the assembly is done in lines and has some similarities to SMT. 

 

Solders, solder pastes, solder wire, solder preforms, and fluxes are used for interconnects in PV assembly.  Since RoHS and WEEE initiative does not apply to this industry, many manufacturers use SnPb solder for interconnects, Sn60 and Sn62 being the most popular. However, SnAg is occasionally used, and some manufacturers are exploring the use of SAC alloys (SnAgCu), specifically SAC305.

 

One process, "cell stringing" or "tabbing", uses products quite familiar to the SMT industry.  Tabbing ribbon, a precisely straight and flat piece of copper that has been coated with a tightly controlled thickness of solder, is used to connect multiple PV cells. 

 

This article discusses the common solders, reflow technologies, and materials used in PV cell stringing for solar module assembly."

 

Nice work Karl!

~Jim

 

IGBT Assembly - Indium8.9LDA Solder Paste

Thursday, March 12, 2009 by Dr. Andy Mackie [Dr. Andy Mackie]

The Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor (IGBT) module is rapidly taking over from MOSFET technology as the solid-state power switch of choice. Die-attach to the direct-bonded copper (DBC) substrate is often done by using a solder paste, or occasionally a specially-shaped solder preform.

Prime drivers for the IGBT die-attach solder assembly process are:
- High thermal and electrical conductivity
- Ultralow voiding (<0.5%)
- 100% cleanability
- Pb-free

This obviously means a wise choice of materials (substrates and solder paste) and both the correct reflow equipment (vacuum soldering is typical, to ensure low voiding) and a 100% effective cleaning process before wirebonding, are all key factors in optimized assembly.

The Indium8.9-LDA solder paste has been developed over the last year, in association with industry leaders in the soldering equipment, cleaning and module-manufacturing fields, to meet the specific needs of global IGBT module manufacturers.
We have both the material, and the data to prove its usefulness.

Yet another example of Indium Corporation leading the Pb-free charge in the Power Semiconductor industry.

Cheers!
- Andy

Indium Die Attach - Room Temperature Soldering

Monday, October 6, 2008 by Amanda Hartnett [Amanda Hartnett]
Etched Indium Ribbon Wound Back on Itself and cold-welded to form a loop.

Etched Indium Ribbon Wound Back on Itself and cold-welded to form a loop.

Die assembly often involves a number of process steps, and may include a solder thermal interface. High temperature solders such as AuSn or SAC solders have been used by some, but a subsegment of the market have overlooked these completely because their chips and assembly components cannot withstand the high temperature soldering that these alloys require. Another solder material that has been considered is indium. Indium has a higher conductivity than these other alloys, is much more compliant, and melts at a significantly lower temperature. Indium solder die attach is a preferred material by many. For an even smaller market subsegment, this method of indium solder attachment still poses issues. It may be that the melting temperature even of pure indium (156C) is too hot or that they cannot use the flux that is required with a soldering process. These customers are looking for a material with the performance of a solder TIM, but room temperature curing temperatures and a flux-free application. Polymer TIMs are what these manufacturers often settle for, but there are other higher performing options to be aware of. One option is a room temperature application of indium. This process involves the pre-attachment of indium to both the backside of the die and substrate. The pre-attachment can be done either with pre-reflowed preforms, or plated indium. Both indium surfaces are cleaned and indium will cold weld to itself. A solder joint has been formed with all its benefits, and the device has not been exposed to any elevated temperatures. For more information on the indium cold welding process, read: Jim Hisert's Blog entry on Indium Bonding and Indium Cold Welding or the Indium Cold Welding Application Note.

An Interview with Michael Qiu 采访邱学丞

Tuesday, August 12, 2008 by Jim Hisert [Jim Hisert]
Michael Qiu of Indium Corporation

Michael Qiu of Indium Corporation

 

Michael Qiu supports Indium Corporation in Eastern China.  I thought an interview with him would be a good chance to see the semiconductor industry from a different perspective.

邱学丞服务于铟泰中国华东区。采访他会是个从另一个角度去认识半导体行业的绝好机会。

 

Jim: How long have you been involved in the semiconductor industry in China?

吉姆:你在中国从事半导体行业多久了?

Michael: I have been in the semiconductor industry in China more than three years. Before that, I spent four years learning IC design, IC manufacture and Package in a University in Shanghai.

邱学丞:有三年多了。在这之前我花了四年时间在上海某大学学习IC设计、制造 (Fab)和封装。

 

Jim: What semiconductor materials are most popular for your customers?

吉姆:在你的客户中哪些半导体材料用的比较多?

Michael: For some semiconductor package customer, silver epoxy is very popular applied to do die attach. As for high power device, paste/SSDA is used popular for die attach. But for some advanced customers who do BGA, FC and WLCSP business, flux or fine power paste is required.

邱学丞:在一些封装厂里,银浆被大量地用来贴芯片于框架上。对那些做大功率器件的客户来说,锡膏或者焊线用来贴芯片比较普遍。而那些做BGA, FCWLCSP的客户,他们需要的则是助焊剂或者精细颗粒锡膏。

 

Jim: What trends do you see in semiconductor package manufacturing in China?

吉姆:你觉得中国半导体封装的趋势如何?

Michael: For [cost sensitive] customers who do Diodes/Transistor package, the manufacture cost will be more and more important.

BGA/FC/CSP package share will increase soon in the near future and more factories will be able to do those packages.

More advanced package like SIP (system in a package) and MCM (multi-chip module) will [become] popular, but this may take several years.

邱学丞:对那些制造二极管或三极管的客户来说,成本对竞争力非常重要。他们对材料的成本以后会愈加敏感。在封装市场中,BGA/FC/CSP市场份额会有迅速的增长,而且会有更多的厂家能做这些封装。还有一些更高端的封装技术,比如SIP (system in a package) MCM (multi-chip module) 会开始流行,当然这得花个好几年时间。

 

Jim: What topics would our customers in China like to see in the Semiconductor Packaging Blog?

吉姆:中国的客户希望在半导体封装博克上看到什么样的话题?

Michael: Our customers always hope to get our professional technical support. They prefer the blog on a particular application or issue. For example, comparison between In and AuSn in LD die attach and use dilute hydrochloric acid to remove oxidation layer on In preforms.

邱学丞:我们的客户总是会希望能得到更好的专业支持。他们会比较喜欢主题明确,针某个具体应用或者问题的一些文章。比如:“LD芯片贴装应用中InAuSn的对比”和“用弱盐酸去除铟焊片表面的氧化物”。

 

Jim: What is the most exciting thing about the semiconductor industry to you?

吉姆:半导体行业中什么东西最让你觉得激动?

Michael: A chip which is smaller than your nail has so many functions.

邱学丞:一个比你指甲还小的芯片能拥有如此多的功能,这太迷人了。