Folks,
Some time ago I wrote a post, “In Search of Tin Whiskers,” Michael responds below. He makes some good points.
Dr. Ron, I'm responding to your blog regarding tin whiskers. I actually have a failure analysis report I did a couple of years ago in which failure of our product was due to this issue and occurred on a part that came into RoHS compliance only 3 months prior.
I'm not sure that your question of identifying whisker issues in product that proper steps have been taken to mitigate the problem is a constructive one. The fact is that many of the component manufacturers from overseas jumped into compliance without any thought or regard to this issue thereby flooding the industry with components such as plagued my company. We have not had this issue since we've specified an alternate finish.
These whiskers are so delicate that most problems disappear when the technician starts to work on the failed unit and the problem never re-appears so it is written off as an anomaly, loose/bad connection and not investigated any further. It was only my own curiosity as to the number of "no problem found" failures of our keypads we had suddenly encountered that caused me to dig deeper and when I looked into the connector I was amazed at the crystal city staring back at me. I couldn't believe what I was seeing after all of these years.
After seeing this problem first hand I became, and am, quite convinced that there were and are people who will be losing life, limb, and property because this forced compliance with its risk was not given proper worldwide attention.
Michael.
A popular topic Re my blog is solder density calculations. Rhonda writes……
Hi Dr. Lasky,
I am a precious metals recycler and would very much appreciate your verifying the validity of an equation that approximates the Karat Value of various alloys of gold based on S.G. which I will call density or "D," and the Karat Value is "K." The equation is seems to hold relatively true even when the exact composition of the alloy is unknown, although the percent of error obviously will increase as density decreases. I would also appreciate not only verification but also more specific information on percent of error for densities below about 14 or 15 g/cc. Here is the equation:
K = 0.0089D^3 - 0.550D^2 + 12.5299D - 77.06
Thank you so much for whatever assistance you can provide.Rhonda
These types of equations can only work for one alloying metal with the gold. This one is only for copper. It is also calibrated in Rhonda’s favor as it reads the karat level about 10% low. I was able to determine this by using the Excel Solder Density worksheet that I developed. If the alloy was gold and lead, a 50% by weight gold (12 karat) would show as 15.7 karat with this equation and Rhonda would lose her shirt.
In response to my blog post on copper as the precursor to civilization, Harvey writes about pollution from early mining operations…..
Also interesting, early copper mining and processing led to the first examples of human induced environmental damage. There are documented sites in the Alps where copper processing by prehistoric peoples has left areas treeless to this day, due to heavy metal contamination.
Harvey
Mining and smelting were very tough businesses in ancient days. In addition to pollution, many workers died from toxic fumes.
Dr. Ron

[Maria Durham: MD] Firstly, the use of lead-(Pb-)containing solders in some soldering applications is restricted due to local environmental and RoHS compliance, but there are still many applications where they are allowed. Many military, aerospace, and industrial equipment uses, as well as many applications related to vehicles, are exempt. The table below shows the most common indium/lead (In/Pb) alloys (pink) and their properties, sorted by liquidus temperature; the higher of the two melting points (solidus and liquidus) seen for non-eutectic alloys. In blue are three comparison materials.
The most common concern regarding this switch relates to the strength of AuSn, which is much higher than the lead solders. The degree that this should be of concern however, should be realized within the scope of the application.
In order for an intermetallic to form, some amount of the surface metallization must dissolve into the molten solder. For this reason, Sn (tin) has long been a critical component of solder alloys. Molten Sn (tin) is an excellent solvent of many other metals. And, conveniently for us, those "many other metals" include elements like copper, gold, silver and, to a lesser degree, nickel. The rates at which these other metals dissolve into molten tin (solder) will differ. Gold dissolves readily into solder; whereas nickel does so slowly. So, because the rate of dissolution is different for each metal, the rate of intermetallic formation is also different. I have dealt with companies that have a long history of soldering to copper, and, for whatever reason, they are forced to switch to an ENIG (Electroless Nickel / Immersion Gold ) surface. (It is important to note that the gold layer is very thin and only applied to protect the nickel from oxidation. This gold layer readily dissolves completely into the molten solder and the "bond" is actually made to the nickel surface). When they make the change they sometimes encounter a number of issues such as incomplete wetting, poor bond strength, etc. and do not know why. They are not aware that the same reflow profile (time and temperature) that yielded a good (intermetallic) bond to copper is not sufficient to get the same intermetallic bond to nickel. Once they adjust their profile (more time and/or higher temperature) to allow for sufficient intermetallic formation , they are able to achieve acceptable solder joints. Keep in mind that dissolution, the phenomenon of a solid dissolving into a liquid, is effected by both time and temperature. Generally speaking, more time and more temperature allows for more dissolution and, hence, more intermetallic formation.
irst case there are 3 Cu atoms to every Sn atom and in the second case 6 Cu atoms to every 5 Sn atoms. In both cases the Cu is being consumed faster than the Sn atoms. Because of this disparity in the reaction, in an exaggerated scenario, little holes or vacancies ("voids") can form in the copper surface.
Folks,
If you have ever handled a piece of 80Au 20Sn solder alloy, one of the things that you might have noticed is that it does not look anything like gold (yellow lustrous metal). In fact, it does not look all that different than tin or any other tin based alloy.
Solder wire
Also: a final big THANK YOU to our friends at 










Although most scientists today feel that alchemy has been widely discredited, and I have been taught to agree, the idea of it is whimsical and exhilarating. Of course, I don’t have a hope of changing the makeup of bismuth or transforming it into another metal, but in a modern way, it’s very interesting how bismuth can be used to change the properties of other metals significantly - through alloying. In my
I suppose if it was still socially acceptable to be an alchemist that is what I would have wanted to be; it just never seemed to be a viable option. What I have chosen to do now kind of makes sense considering chemistry/metallurgy is about as close as you can get nowadays. 

